Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


'Twilight': Who would you recast?

We asked fans if you had the power, would you replace Robert Pattinson with a different Edward? Is there a better Bella than Kristen Stewart? Does the supporting cast match what you imagined from the book? Here’s what you said…

Posted on

Kristen Stewart: Peter Sorel; Emily Browning: Kristian Dowling/Getty Images; Kat Dennings: Steve Granitz/WireImage; Lucy Hale: Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

Robert Pattinson: Deana Newcomb; Sean Faris: Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage; Gaspard Ulliel: Tony Barson/WireImage; Ed Westwick: Jim Spellman/WireImage

Taylor Lautner: Deana Newcomb; Steven Strait: Sean Gallup/Getty Images; Shia LaBeouf: Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Peter Facinelli: Deana Newcomb; Justin Hartley: David Livingston/Getty Images; Ryan Gosling: Charles Eshelman/FilmMagic; Jesse Spencer: Michael Buckner/Getty Images

Elizabeth Reaser: Mark Mainz/Getty Images; Emmy Rossum: Mark Von Holden/WireImage; Anne Hathaway: Stephen Lovekin/Getty Images; Carla Gugino: Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Ashley Greene: Deana Newcomb; Rachael Leigh Cook: Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic; Olivia Thirlby: Michael Caulfield/Getty Images; Brea Grant: Michael Tran/FilmMagic

Kellan Lutz: Deana Newcomb; Channing Tatum: Phillip Caruso; Daniel Cudmore: Steve Granitz/WireImage; Tom Welling: James White/The WB

Nikki Reed: Peter Sorel; Megan Fox: Kevin Winter/Getty Images; Olivia Wilde: Chris Haston/Fox; Ali Larter : Mitchell Haaseth/NBC

Jackson Rathbone: Deana Newcomb; Trent Ford : Mark Mainz/Getty Images; Garrett Hedlund: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images; Chace Crawford: Eric Liebowitz /The CW

Cam Gigandet: Peter Sorel; Cillian Murphy: Vera Anderson/WireImage; Elijah Wood: Eduardo Parra/FilmMagic; Ben Barnes: Jeff Vespa/WireImage

Rachelle LeFevre: Peter Sorel; Kata Dobo: MJ Kim/Getty Images; Milla Jovovich: George Pimentel/WireImage; Rose McGowan: Matt Carr/Getty Images

Edi Gathegi: Peter Sorel; John Stamos: Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic; Jason Isaacs: Matt Carr/Getty Images

Billy Burke: Deana Newcomb; Billy Campbell: Alan Zenuk/USA; John C. Reilly: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images; Jeffrey Dean Morgan: Todd Williamson/WireImage

More Twilight coverage from EW:
EW’s Twilight Central

Entertainers of the Year: Stephenie Meyer

Twilight: The EW review

Twilight trivia challenge!

Twilight: What’s Next?