Entertainment Weekly

Subscribe

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Leona Lewis' borrowed songs

Kelly Clarkson and Roberta Flack may have sang them first, but does Leona Lewis sing them better?

Posted on

Leona Lewis’ borrowed songs

LEONA LEWIS VS JESSE McCARTNEY: ”Bleeding Love”
The barely legal heartthrob co-wrote this smash with OneRepublic’s Ryan Tedder, so he had every right to record his own version. But where his thin, thready vocals make the pain sound like a paper cut, Lewis’ powerful take slices straight to the core. Winner: Leona Lewis

LEONA LEWIS VS KELLY CLARKSON: ”A Moment Like This”
Clarkson and Lewis both released this ballad as a single after winning their respective competitions (American Idol and the U.K.’s The X Factor), and each aptly applies powerhouse pipes. Still, when the chorus hits, it’s Clarkson who gives you chills. Winner: Kelly Clarkson

LEONA LEWIS VS ROBERTA FLACK: ”The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face”
It takes guts to take on the signature song of one of the most distinctive vocalists from the ’70s — so Lewis wisely avoids a direct Xerox. Problem is, Flack’s butterscotch rasp is just too perfect — her rendition is basically untouchable. Winner: Roberta Flack