Entertainment Weekly

Subscribe

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Is ''Gattaca'' worth the upgrade?

We compare the old DVD to the new special edition of the Ethan Hawke film

Posted on

Picture a future world where genetic engineering has created rampant birth-defect discrimination. A new special edition (PG-13, 106 mins., 1997) reworks the DNA of the original DVD. But is it a better breed?

ORIGINAL
The ’98 disc offered wide-screen and full-screen options. But some rental copies were full-screen only, which brutally cropped the images and sometimes made it impossible to see soon-to-be-married, now-divorced costars Ethan Hawke and Uma Thurman in the same frame. The extras — including a bland ”documentary” that’s just an extended commercial, deleted scenes (like an epilogue gallery of genetically ”in-valid” people), and set photos — were okay.

REISSUE
Needs more lab work. The same lame, low-quality menu pages frame basically the same old extras, garnished by two blah new featurettes: a brief segment on genetic-research history and a 21-minute paean to the movie that’s rife with platitudinous interviews. Hawke and costar Jude Law contribute, but there’s nothing from Thurman or, oddly, writer-director Andrew Niccol.

VERDICT
Gattaca‘s a smart, inventive sci-fi tale worth renting or buying if it’s new to you. But an upgrade if you already own? Test results say negative.