Michael Slezak
March 11, 2008 AT 03:49 PM EDT

EW critic Ken Tucker and I continue our recent debate over who’s the better singer, Kelly Clarkson or Bob Dylan, then throw down on the ideal song choices for Idol contestants Brooke White, David Hernandez, and Carly Smithson. Let’s hear your request lists in the comments section below.

You May Like

Comments

EDIT POST