We gave it a C+
Working in the Caribbean for the summer, teenager Jenny (She’s the Man‘s Bynes) is ecstatic to find herself ”stranded” on a deserted island with her pop-star crush (The O.C.‘s Carmack). So ecstatic that she never reveals they’re only footsteps from their resort. Bynes is believable as a crazy fan in Lovewrecked, and star cameos (Kathy Griffin, Jamie-Lynn Sigler, Fred Willard) are hilarious, but in the end, the unrealistic plot twists — conveniently, the search party never discovers them! — sink this schmaltzy romantic comedy.
EXTRAS Three pointless deleted scenes.