Gilbert Cruz
November 10, 2006 AT 05:00 AM EST

The Lost

type
Book
Current Status
In Season
author
Daniel Mendelsohn
publisher
HarperCollins
genre
Nonfiction

We gave it a B

In The Lost, Daniel Mendelsohn recounts his search for the circumstances of the deaths of his great uncle Shmiel and five other members of his Jewish Ukrainian family. The book is many things: a family history, a meditation on Jewishness (with frustratingly academic looks at biblical texts), and a detective story, as Mendelsohn travels from Ukraine to Australia to Israel to Denmark in search of elderly Jews who might be able to fill him in on the details of his kin’s final living months. The Lost is at times moving, though the emotion is frequently undercut by the author’s meandering digressions and winding sentences (one particularly egregious example is 179 words long), on the whole similar to the way Mendelsohn’s grandfather would tell stories, ”all that background, all those Chinese boxes; and then, suddenly, the swift and expert slide into the finale.”

You May Like

Comments

EDIT POST