Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Is ''Bad Santa'' worth the upgrade?

See what we thought of the new director’s cut

Posted on

Is ”Bad Santa” worth the upgrade?

A midnight-black twist on the traditional Christmas flick, this Billy Bob Thornton pic mixed unabashedly crude comedy with Hollywood sweetness. Did a new director’s cut jingle our bells?

ORIGINAL
Neither initial ’04 DVD release (the R-rated Bad Santa or the unrated Badder Santa) had much involvement from director Terry Zwigoff. They made do with a cursory making-of, some deleted scenes (the best being a Sarah Silverman cameo as a ”Santa trainer”), and a fistful of set outtakes.

REISSUE
With its ”director-approved” seal, this DVD offers a ”more emotionally truthful” version of the lowbrow Xmas flick, as Zwigoff says on a new commentary with editor Robert Hoffman. Ironically, the director’s cut is three minutes shorter than the theatrical.

VERDICT
Worth the upgrade? Not really. There are interesting nuggets on the commentary — ”Grandma” Cloris Leachman wanted to play her role in the nude — but despite Zwigoff’s complaints about studio interference, his drier, darker director’s cut just isn’t that different from the original. Save your holiday bonus for something else.

Comments