Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Is ''Rescue Me'' jumping the shark?

Is ”Rescue Me” jumping the shark? Check out today’s Ask the Critic question and post your own

Posted on

Rescue Me: Eric Liebowitz

Is ”Rescue Me” jumping the shark?

Do the recent ”actions” on Rescue Me qualify as ”jumping the shark”? I don’t think so, but the talk going around online tells me otherwise. —Aleks Chan

Let’s see, Aleks, do you mean the episode in which Sheila (Callie Thorne) drugged and date-raped Tommy (Denis Leary)? Or the time that Sexy Older Lady (guest star Susan Sarandon) basically stole Franco’s daughter — and Franco (Daniel Sunjata) kinda wrote it off, except for a temper tantrum and some wistfulness? I could name a half dozen other oh-come-on! moments in season 3, but I’d actually agree with you. It’s less a case of ”jumping the shark” than ”grabbing shiny object.” Rescue Me — which I should add I’ll never stop watching — can’t sit still enough to play out a plotline. Heck, the writers killed off Tommy’s son and can’t even keep that as a thread. Still, despite my sniping, there are few better ensemble casts on TV: Dean Winters, as Tommy’s ex-wife-snatching brother, is a great, cool foil to hothead Leary, and breezy Marisa Tomei should be convinced to join as a regular. Bonus points for giving more screen time to Steven Pasquale, as dim-bulb Sean Garrity. You’ve got to love anyone who can convincingly court Tatum O’Neal and pull off a sleep-walking scene — which was easily one of the summer’s funniest moments.

(Got a TV-related question for Gillian? Post it here.)