We gave it an A-
If the prospect of seeing Alec Baldwin bumping and grinding in a grass skirt and coconut bra isn’t enough to entice you, rest assured that South Pacific in Concert From Carnegie Hall, this June 2005 staging has plenty of other virtues: a Rodgers & Hammerstein score that spawned more standards than any other; Broadway’s favorite leading man, Brian Stokes Mitchell, lending his beautiful baritone to the still-fresh ”Some Enchanted Evening” and the heartbreaking ”This Nearly Was Mine”; country-turned-TV star Reba McEntire — no stranger to the stage, after her well-reviewed replacement stint in Annie Get Your Gun a few years back — charming the natives (”A Cockeyed Optimist”), slaying ’em in a sailor suit (”Honey Bun”), and proving once and for all that she’s a theater performer to be reckoned with. (Not to be forgotten: Jason Danieley’s wonderfully conflicted Lieutenant Cable, who loves that younger-than-springtime island girl Liat.) As for the concert format, fret not: ”I’m Gonna Wash That Man Right Outa My Hair” works even without a headful of shampoo. EXTRAS None, but Baldwin shaking his coconuts is a bonus feature in itself.