Entertainment Weekly

Subscribe

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Evening In The Palace Of Reason

Posted on

J.S. Bach’s 1747 command performance for Frederick the Great was no ordinary concert, argues former Time and People editor James R. Gaines, but a battle of values between the young Prussian monarch’s Enlightenment rationality and the aged composer’s faith-based worldview. Further, the musical offering Bach later dedicated to Frederick was a veiled rebuke, an ”exploding bouquet.” Though Gaines’ premise doesn’t totally convince — nor does his theory about Frederick’s malice toward Bach — he maps sweeping cultural history onto his dual biography with dazzling virtuosity. Gaines clearly sides with Bach, while Frederick is portrayed less sympathetically as a connoisseur of gizmos like the flatulent mechanical duck. But if you’ve ever wondered about the metaphysics behind Bach’s music, you won’t find a more lucid and engaging guide.