Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Who won EW.com's Reality TV Poll? Find out!

You voted for your favorite reality TV star, villain, and host in 2004 — now see who came in No. 1

Posted on

Clay Aiken

Clay Aiken may not have won ”American Idol,” but now he has a prize to call his own. With a total of 6,164 votes cast in the EW.com Reality TV Poll, you named the scrawny crooner your favorite reality-TV star, giving him 23 percent of the vote. The Clayster beat out ”Survivor: Pearl Islands”’ Rupert Boneham (17 percent), ”Newlyweds”’ Jessica Simpson (10 percent), and even fellow Idol Kelly Clarkson (15 percent). Meanwhile, tying for last place, with 1 percent each, were schlumpy Adam Mesh of ”Average Joe,” eyeliner-loving Tammy Faye Messner of ”The Surreal Life 2,” ”Joe Millionaire”’s first ”winner” Zora Andrich, and Trista Rehn of ”The Bachelor”/”Bachelorette” franchise.

As for the reality-TV star you love to hate, the winner’s identity is no surprise: It’s ”The Apprentice”’s Omarosa Manigualt-Stallworth, with 35 percent of the vote. The similarly conniving Jon Dalton of ”Survivor: Pearl Islands”) nabbed 12 percent, Paris Hilton (”The Simple Life”) got 8 percent, and repeat reality-show offender Trishelle Cannatella (”The Real World: Las Vegas,” ”The Surreal Life 2”) garnered 6 percent.

Meanwhile, our condolences to Ryan Seacrest — he lost out big-time to ”Survivor”’s Jeff Probst as favorite reality-TV host (Probst got 43 percent, while Seacrest got 25 percent). In other words: Seacrest… out.