We gave it a C+
Five for Fighting auteur John Ondrasik is a man fighting against his own strengths. With his sweetened falsetto and knack for supple hooks and unrequited-love lyrics, he’s a natural lite FM balladeer (heard here on ”Maybe I” and ”Dying”). But deep down, he yearns to be a serious artist making grand statements. The band’s third CD is weighed down by artificially inflated anthems, garbled lyrics about the apocalypse, and coy attempts at surrealism. Ondrasik’s ambition is admirable, but not always listenable.