Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


We grade the latest ''American Idol'' performances

Posted on

Tamyra Gray, American Idol
Tamyra Gray: Fox

The judges’ favorite (shown), decked out in a pin striped suit with flowers in her slicked-back hair, kicked off the show on the highest of notes with a brilliantly bluesy ”Minnie the Moocher.” After her scat-tastic performance, Randy said she could ”sing the phone book and make it sound good,” while Simon gushed, ”How did you remain undiscovered for so long?” A

After last week on loser row, Justin needed a comeback song. He might have been served a little better by a slow, swoon-worthy Chet Baker number, but he performed the hell out of the ever-cool ”Route 66.” He certainly looked the lust-worthy part in a fitted tuxedo with an untied bowtie, and the judges fell for him all over again. Simon hailed the peformance as ”great,” while Randy pronounced, ”Justin is back. That was fabulous.” A-