Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Hit Or Miscasting

Posted on

Hollywood casts the movies, and we cast doubt. Here’s our assessment of some recently reported role calls. — Brian M. Raftery

FILM The Pink Panther returns under director Ivan Reitman (Ghostbusters). STAR High-pitched (and high-paid) motormouth Chris Tucker as bumbling Inspector Clouseau. VERDICT He’s done French farce before — in Luc Besson’s 1997 The Fifth Element — but Tucker will have to tone it down to play this breed of cool cat. B-

FILM Untitled biopic of suicidal poet Sylvia Plath. STAR Jarring belle Gwyneth Paltrow. VERDICT After essaying writers in The Royal Tenenbaums and the upcoming Possession, the oft-pouty Paltrow seems word-perfect to play literature’s most vexed verse vixen. This one will be like Star Wars for sullen 14-year-old girls everywhere. A

FILM CBS’ biopic of Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis. STAR Jeremy Northam (Gosford Park) as the stick-swizzling singer. VERDICT With a properly cocked eyebrow, a tuxed Northam could be a ring-a-ding dead ringer — and balance manic Sean Hayes (Will & Grace) as Lewis. Just don’t warble ”That’s Amore” with a British accent. B+

FILM A John Woo-produced update on the justly antiquated Charlie Chan detective series. STAR Charlie girl Lucy Liu, playing Chan’s crime-solving granddaughter. VERDICT Confucius say: Why bring back Chan? And despite the gender spin, the biggest unsolved mystery may be whether Liu can carry a picture all by herself. B