Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Best Director

Posted on

ROBERT ALTMAN FOR HIM Juggling 23 actors in Gosford Park earned the 77-year-old maverick (and this year’s Golden Globe and AFI winner) his fifth nod. Since he’s never won, a trophy now could be a de facto lifetime achievement award. AGAINST HIM He wasn’t even nominated by the Directors Guild. Compared with the more visually elaborate competition, was his effort a walk in the Park? 5-2 ODDS

RON HOWARD FOR HIM After 15 features, the filmmaker formerly known as Opie finally scored an Oscar nod for the affecting A Beautiful Mind; after this complex effort (and a second DGA prize), the Academy simply can’t ignore him anymore. AGAINST HIM Or can they? Voters seem to love actor-directors (Eastwood, Costner, Gibson). Do they feel the same about former actors as directors? 2-1 ODDS

PETER JACKSON FOR HIM If the award were for most directing, he’d be a lock; he oversaw the largest production of the year, bringing scope and humanity to the first of the three Lord of the Rings films; awarding him now means not having to bother for the next two. AGAINST HIM Directors rarely win for fantasies (George Lucas lost to Woody Allen); he’s not exactly a Hollywood name. 3-2 ODDS

DAVID LYNCH FOR HIM Anyone who can turn a failed TV pilot into a thrilling, even moving mystery with essentially zero plot resolution deserves a prize (and indeed, he’s already won five for Mulholland Drive); his name is synonymous with the phrase ”singular vision.” AGAINST HIM A Best Director win off the film’s only nomination? That would make about as much sense as the film. 20-1 ODDS

RIDLEY SCOTT FOR HIM Today’s most versatile blockbuster maker has scored his second nomination in a row with the formidable Black Hawk Down, whose hyperrealistic battle scenes were reminiscent of Steven Spielberg’s Oscar-winning work in Saving Private Ryan. AGAINST HIM The film wasn’t nominated for any other major award. If he couldn’t win for Gladiator, he won’t for this. 15-1 ODDS

THE LOWDOWN In the night’s tightest three-way race, Howard and Altman are strong contenders, but Jackson may grab the golden ring.

Comments