Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Stage Review: 'Spinning Into Butter'

Posted on

Spinning into Butter

Current Status:
In Season
Hope Davis
Daniel Sullivan
Rebecca Gilman

We gave it a B

After a controversial run at Chicago’s Goodman Theater, Spinning Into Butter marks the New York debut of acclaimed 35-year-old writer Rebecca Gilman. It’s an earnest, tough-minded piece about a racial incident at a privileged Vermont college. The first act unfolds like a comedy of manners, as its characters traverse a minefield of coded, loaded jargon meant to neutralize the issue of race. But the second act rips at those pieties in brave fashion. Gilman allows her heroine — a sympathetic dean played by Hope Davis (Arlington Road) — to reveal some ugly and galvanizing truths about herself. The play is compelling, if occasionally brittle, and it will adjust your sensitivities. B