Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Hit and Miscasting

From Tobey Maguire in ‘Spider Man’ to Roberto Benigni in ‘Pinocchio,’ we review the casting of upcoming films

Posted on

Why wait for the movie to come out before passing judgment? Let’s rate these high-profile castings — all reportedly in the works — and call it a day.

FILM The much-anticipated big-screen Spider-Man
STAR Tobey Maguire
OUR VERDICT Doesn’t bug us at all. The Cider House Rules star — who beat out the likes of Scott Speedman and Freddie Prinze Jr. — has reportedly been bulking up for the skintight red suit. And he’s demonstrated he can play a sensitive, Peter Parker-style nerd in … pretty much every movie he’s ever been in. A

FILM Live-action version of puppet boy Pinocchio
STAR Roberto Benigni
OUR VERDICT The jabbering, jittering Italian actor is going to play wooden? Theezz eezz not byoo-ti-ful! Of course, there’s a chance the 47-year-old would play Geppetto. What a waste of his manic energy. Please pull some strings to save us! C

FILM ABC biopic of tennis champ Billie Jean King
STAR Holly Hunter
OUR VERDICT The Piano star has the women’s rights advocate’s spunk. Plus: A penchant for on-screen nakedness proves she’s in shape to play the Wimbledon ace. B+