Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Why ''Galaxy Quest'' outshines Hanks' and Carrey's new films

Posted on

Why ”Galaxy Quest” outshines Hanks’ and Carrey’s new films

I must admit I went to ”Galaxy Quest” over the weekend not expecting much — my 10-year-old wanted to see it, and I was along for the ride. What a pleasant shock the movie proved to be, however. This canny spoof of ”Star Trek” fandom — about the cast of a canceled sci-fi TV show who are mistaken for real space heroes by a group of aliens who need help in their battle against an intergalactic monster villain — was at once sweet-tempered and sharp-witted, and ultimately touchingly insightful about the gonzo young fan-boys the movie only seems to caricature.

By chance, I also saw another outer-space-titled film — ”Man on the Moon,” the all too down-to-earth biopic starring Jim Carrey as Andy Kaufman — this weekend, and recently caught the Tom Hanks marathon ”The Green Mile,” three-plus hours of mice, moldy jail cells, and moral uplift. These two movies are big-budget, big-star jobs positioned as Oscar magnets. But ”Green Mile” presents Hanks, an actor I (and of course millions of other people) enjoy, as a stiff saint; the movie doesn’t allow him to create the vivid, flawed character that would make his role as a thoughtful prison guard a moving one.

And other than admiring Carrey’s dead-on impersonation of Kaufman, ”Moon” struck me as a rather cold, tedious exercise. Director Milos Forman restages Kaufman’s most famous ”bits” — his ”Mighty Mouse” lip-synching routine, his wrestling matches with women — with scrupulous fidelity, but watching this re-creation of comedy places it at a distance that doesn’t encourage laughter. Had the movie explored the man behind the moon-faced grin, Forman might have created the portrait of a misunderstood comic genius he intends, but there’s nothing here beneath the surface of this ”Moon.”

”Galaxy Quest,” by contrast, has a funny premise that’s carried off with brisk efficiency. Tim Allen, who stars as the film’s TV-show commander, is no Jim Carrey in the acting department, but he’s perfect as a TV star who hasn’t succumbed to a has-been’s cynicism. Three actors who ARE up to Carrey level — Sigourney Weaver, Alan Rickman, and Tony Shalhoub — frequently transcend the script’s foolishness to achieve a beguiling playfulness. The movie’s laughs are blessedly unironic, as opposed to Kaufman’s increasingly dated-looking ironic ”happenings.” And unlike ”The Green Mile,” ”Galaxy” works as both a genre piece and as a comment on humanity. In ”Quest”’s case, it’s suggested that even junk culture can provide people with emotional nourishment if it’s presented with heart.

Call me a sentimental low-brow, but I think that’s a notion worth celebrating. The fact that it arrives surrounded by belly laughs only makes the modest ”Galaxy Quest” more of a pleasure.

Comments