Entertainment Weekly

Subscribe

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Movie Review: 'Telling Lies in America'

Posted on

Telling Lies in America

type:
Movie
Current Status:
In Season
mpaa:
PG-13
performer:
Kevin Bacon, Calista Flockhart, Joe Eszterhaus, Brad Renfro
director:
Guy Ferland
genre:
Drama

We gave it a C+

Telling Lies in America Kevin Bacon’s passionate, sharply drawn portrayal of Billy Magic, a slick, finger-snapping, payola-pocketing disc jockey in early 1960s Cleveland, is the best thing about this conventional but heartfelt semiautobiographical coming-of-age story, written by Joe Eszterhas — who knew he was such a big softie? — and directed with an eye for nostalgia by Guy Ferland (The Babysitter). Unfortunately, it’s not Billy Magic’s story we’re here to ponder. The stage belongs to Eszterhas stand-in Karchy Jonas (The Client’s Brad Renfro, working stiffly), an ostracized Hungarian-born teenager trying to find a place for himself in rock & roll America, who, displaying a survivor’s instinct for subterfuge and self-invention, is taken on by Billy as a malleable gofer. Everything he knows about America, Eszterhas seems to be saying, he learned from a compromised mentor who dazzled and betrayed him. Yet Karchy himself is never more than a sketch of a young man, his path to American-ness far less interesting than Billy’s reckless, post-Quiz Show-era road to ruin. Teaching young Karchy about love, meanwhile, is Calista Flockhart (TV’s Ally McBeal) as a nice girl who expects better of her beaux than the bluster of a raw-boned immigrant. C+