Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


''Marvin's Room'' versus ''The Evening Star''

We look at the similarities between the two tragicomedies

Posted on

If you go by morals, Marvin’s Room is a much better movie than The Evening Star. Marvin’s says to love loving: ”I’m so lucky to have had so much love in my life,” explains Diane Keaton’s Bessie. Star, a Terms of Endearment sequel, selfishly teaches to love being loved: ”I was in a place. I had a daughter. And I was loved,” whispers Shirley MacLaine’s Aurora. But in every other respect, the two tragicomedies fill in the same blanks.

Early on…

in MARVIN’S ROOM/THE EVENING STAR, first-time director JERRY ZAKS/ROBERT HARLING shows us a child rummaging through family snapshots — a theme that returns to POWERFUL/MAUDLIN effect.


LEE (MERYL STREEP)/AURORA bickers with her incarcerated SON HANK (LEONARDO DICAPRIO)/GRANDSON TOMMY (GEORGE NEWBERN) and brings him sweets he doesn’t eat. So we learn independent LEE/AURORA has alienated her KIDS/KID’S KIDS and must accept responsibility.


as LEE AND BESSIE/AURORA AND PATSY (MIRANDA RICHARDSON) passively compete for affection, HANK/MELANIE (JULIETTE LEWIS) gets ticked and steals a car — but returns.


attempting to sort herself out, BESSIE/AURORA visits a quacky specialist, DR. WALLY (ROBERT DE NIRO)/JERRY (BILL PAXTON), who only makes things worse.


in an uplifting moment, BESSIE AND HANK/AURORA AND GARRETT (JACK NICHOLSON) have a heart-to-heart in the backyard, then take a life-affirming joyride on the beach.

In all…

three beloved characters are doomed, including nonsense-sputtering, bushy-eyebrowed former military man MARVIN (HUME CRONYN)/HECTOR (DONALD MOFFAT) and softhearted RUTH (GWEN VERDON)/ROSIE (MARION ROSS).

As things progress…

BESSIE/AURORA insists MARVIN/ROSIE be allowed to die at home — a touching scene has her wearily spilling pills in the kitchen — then she deteriorates herself.


LEE AND HANK/MELANIE, TOMMY, AND PATSY make up with BESSIE/AURORA as the end nears. And the credits roll.