Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


That Old Feeling

Posted on

The old feeling director Carl Reiner and screenwriter Leslie Dixon have in mind for That Old Feeling is the hotcha-cha attraction that resurfaces between over-flamboyant exes Lilly (Bette Midler) and Dan (Dennis Farina), when they meet up again at the wedding of their under-flamboyant daughter (wholesome Chicago Sons regular Paula Marshall) to a prig with political ambitions (Jamie Denton). The old feeling this coarse, braying, unimaginative comedy evokes, however, is La Cage aux Folles-itis — a growing irritability at displays of campy bitchiness substituting for a real sense of humor. Midler, in particular, is in tarnished full-brassy mode. Remarried to a psychobabbling marriage counselor, played by the always amusing David Rasche, Lilly spoils for a catfight with Dan’s second, trophy wife (NYPD Blue alumna Gail O’Grady, showing a nice comedic ability) by resorting to that tiredest of First Wives Club tricks: dishing her rival’s surgically enhanced appearance. Hollywood ladies (and, particularly, beloved Bette), please, can we call a moratorium on shtick about what ”work” a woman has had done? The obsession is, like, tacky.