Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


These songs stick around

Remakes of ”Lean on Me,” ”Killing Me Softly,” and more extend the life of these famous one-hit wonders

Posted on

Even the most cautious Vegas bookies are betting that ”Macarena” is bound for one-hit-wonder heaven. However, the singular sensations that truly grate are remakes, especially by those who ride a note-for-note cover version to the top of the charts. Warning to Fugees: As this chronology suggests, invest wisely.

Juice Newton ”Angel of the Morning” (No. 4, 1981) Original Version by: Merrilee Rush (1968) Justification for Remake: After several hitless albums, Newton desperately needed a smash. Attempt at Fresh Twist: Many fewer violins than Rush’s original; otherwise identical. Satan’s Payback: Newton has been absent from the top 40 since 1983; currently playing Vegas.

Club Nouveau ”Lean on Me” (No. 1, 1987) Original Version by: Bill Withers (1972) Justification for Remake: R&B song with comforting ”you’ve got a friend” message relevant during Reagan-era budget cuts. Attempt at Fresh Twist: Electro-dance beat courtesy of two of its members (and future En Vogue Svengalis), Denzil Foster and Thomas McElroy. Satan’s Payback: Club who?

Big Mountain ”Baby I Love Your Way” (No. 6, 1994) Original Version by: Peter Frampton (1976) Justification for Remake: Requisite oldies revival for movie soundtrack (in this case, Reality Bites). Attempt at Fresh Twist: Watered-down reggae riddim makes song sound even wimpier than Frampton’s original. Satan’s Payback: The band’s white-guy dreadlocks dated even faster than Ethan Hawke’s goatee.

Nicki French ”Total Eclipse of the Heart” (No. 2, 1995) Original Version by: Bonnie Tyler (1983) Justification for Remake: Meat Loaf’s blue-plate comeback made viable the unsavory idea of reviving tunes by his partner (and ”Eclipse” author) Jim Steinman. Attempt at Fresh Twist: Dance-club beat, but French does a solid imitation of Tyler’s trademark rasp. Satan’s Payback: Even with a hit, debut album fails to break into Billboard‘s Hot 100 chart.

Fugees ”Killing Me Softly” (1996) Original Version by: Roberta Flack (1973) Justification for Remake: Singer Lauryn Hill seeks to rekindle pleasant childhood memories of singing along with Flack’s soothing ’70s hit. Attempt at Fresh Twist: Mild-mannered hip-hop drum track, which makes it sound like — uh, Roberta Flack with a mild-mannered hip-hop drum track. Satan’s Payback: Ink still drying on contract.