Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Emmys 2017
Every unforgettable moment, every gorgeous dress.Click here


Book Review: 'The Horse Whisperer'

Posted on

The Horse Whisperer

Current Status:
In Season
164 minutes
Robert Redford, Kristin Scott-Thomas, Kate Bosworth, Chris Cooper, Scarlett Johansson, Cherry Jones, Sam Neill, Dianne Wiest
Robert Redford
Touchstone Pictures
Richard LaGravenese, Eric Roth
Drama, Romance

We gave it a C-

The book you’re likely to read about, hear about, and — if the publicity department at Delacorte could arrange it — dream about is Nicholas Evans’ first novel, THE HORSE WHISPERER. Not only is it soon to be a major motion picture (Hollywood Pictures and Robert Redford’s production company, Wildwood, bought the rights for $3 million), it’s already a major motion picture. For one thing, Evans relies on crosscutting and other cinematic techniques. For another, a lot of money is involved: Delacorte paid $3.15 million for this novel, the publishing equivalent of Waterworld.

All the fuss is over a simple story of a girl and her horse. And her mother. And a lean, laconic but profound cowboy. One winter morning 13-year-old Grace Maclean goes out riding in upstate New York. What follows is the most carefully orchestrated riding accident in American fiction, involving a slippery slope and a wayward 40-ton truck. Grace loses her leg and her horse, Pilgrim, who is crazed by the ordeal and won’t let anyone near him.

Except maybe Tom Booker, who lives on a ranch in Montana and coaxes horses out of their troubles for a living. Grace’s mother, Annie, a hard-edged New York magazine editor, persuades Tom to work his magic on the horse and retrieve her daughter’s spirits in the process. Annie doesn’t guess that she will fall under Tom’s spell too. But the reader does, and after the early chapters there’s not much to do but wait for the inevitable. But the book is not all bad news. There’s some fine psychological shading in the mother-daughter relationship and considerable authenticity of detail — horses, landscapes, kids. But then again, there were good moments in Waterworld, too. C-