Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Emmys 2017
Every unforgettable moment, every gorgeous dress.Click here


''Real World'' Rejection

EW talks to some of the twenty-somethings turned down by MTV’s hit reality show

Posted on

Last year some 25,000 people competed for the privilege of sharing their food with the finger-lickin’ Puck. After submitting 17-page essays and homemade videos and surviving seven rounds of interviews, all but seven Real World roommate wannabes found themselves the unhappy recipients of a letter that began, ”This is very difficult for us to write….” The selection process left few personality quirks unexplored: aspirant (and former EW intern) Heather Beach was asked, ”Would you ever want to sleep with David Letterman?” (She didn’t.) The losers have one consolation: They’re not airing their dirty laundry — underwear included — on TV. But are they bitter?

Well, they aren’t exactly rooting for the show. ”They did a lousy job of picking the people,” says Beach, 21. ”They’re so boring and stereotyped, even more cookie-cutter than usual.” (She does admire the million-dollar Real World mansion. ”When I saw the house on Lombard Street,” she says, ”I turned green.”)

”Judd?” gasps Real World washout Shayne Ireland, 28, an advertising executive. ”Limp noodle! I mean, get some personality! He just sits there picking his nose. Well, no, that’s Puck.” Yeah, that is Puck. ”I know I’d have a problem with him if I were on the show,” Ireland continues. ”I’m way more hygienically sound than he is.”

”I’ve been having nightmares that I lived with these people,” confides rebuffed Anna David, 24, an editorial associate for Parenting magazine (also a former EW intern). ”What is my problem? I’m never thinking about the Real World again.”

Despite their disdain for the winners, some outcasts remain a bit sensitive about the experience. Media planner Amy Levitin, 23, asks nervously, ”You’re not going to reject me from the reject article, are you?”