Entertainment Weekly

Subscribe

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

CRITICAL MASS

Posted on

Here’s how our reviewer and other film critics from across the country grade these current movies. CLIFFHANGER

C Peter Travers Rolling Stone C Mike Clark USA Today D Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert B Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert C Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer A Jami Bernard The New York Post B- Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=C+

DAVE

B+ Peter Travers Rolling Stone B+ Mike Clark USA Today B Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert ; B+ Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert B Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer A Jami Bernard The New York Post B+ Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=B+

GUILTY AS SIN

D Peter Travers Rolling Stone C- Mike Clark USA Today D Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert B Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert C+ Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer D Jami Bernard The New York Post B Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=C

HOT SHOTS! PART DEUX

C+ Peter Travers Rolling Stone C- Mike Clark USA Today B Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert B- Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert C+ Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer C+ Jami Bernard The New York Post C+ Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=C+

LIKE WATER FOR CHOCOLATE

B Peter Travers Rolling Stone B+ Mike Clark USA Today B+ Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert A Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert B+ Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer A- Jami Bernard The New York Post B- Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=B+

MADE IN AMERICA

D Peter Travers Rolling Stone D- Mike Clark USA Today D Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert B- Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert C+ Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer C+ Jami Bernard The New York Post C+ Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=C-

MENACE II SOCIETY

A- Peter Travers Rolling Stone B Mike Clark USA Today A- Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert A Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert B Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer – Jami Bernard The New York Post A Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=A-

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING

C- Peter Travers Rolling Stone B+ Mike Clark USA Today ! C+ Gene Siskel Siskel & Ebert B+ Roger Ebert Siskel & Ebert A- Carrie Rickey Philadelphia Inquirer A- Jami Bernard The New York Post A- Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly AVERAGE=B