Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

Confrontational news

From ”Crossfire” to ”Meet the Press,” we rate weekly political chat programs

Posted on

CROSSFIRE
* The Players Michael Kinsley, John Sununu, and target news makers in the middle
* The Rules He who asks the cleverest partisan questions is the cutest. He who executes the fastest rhetorical footwork is the sexiest. Well-formed, complete sentences are a must.
* What to Watch For Kinsley’s faint grins before he pounces, Sununu’s pursed puss before he attacks, and the snarky left-right jabs at the end of each show
* Grade: B For having opinions about everything, every night

THE CAPITAL GANG
* The Players Moderator Al Hunt and three inside-the-Beltway gang members of varying political persuasions
* The Rules Unabashed rip-off of The McLaughlin Group, only with less drama and less-glamorous production values
* What to Watch For Hunt, looking intent, trying to work up McLaughlin-like charisma and hoping to be parodied by Saturday Night Live.
* Grade: C Too stiff to be freewheeling, too much same old same old

THE MCLAUGHLIN GROUP
* The Players Moderator John McLaughlin and four journalists who wear their points of view like boutonnieres
* The Rules The moderator gets to bully and lecture; the panelists get to withstand and defend.
* What to Watch For Wacky signature phrases (”Freddy-the-beadle-Bahhhns!”), wacky signature psychodynamics (McLaughlin picking on Kondracke, Barnes battling Clift, Germond disliking everyone), wacky resemblance to The Gong Show
* Grade: A For being so very What It Is

MEET THE PRESS
* The Players NBC News Washington bureau chief Tim Russert, two reporters (such as Andrea Mitchell, David Broder, R.W. Apple), and the news makers they grill
* The Rules We’re all friendly adversaries on this bus. The questioning, while tough, is dignified, as befits the 45-year-old, longest-running program on network TV.
* What to Watch For A bright-eyed Russert trying (since the program expanded to an hour last month) to beef up the pit-bull factor by jabbing and prodding guests with more gusto
* Grade: B+ The plus is for effort

THIS WEEK WITH DAVID BRINKLEY
* The Players The Grand Old Man himself, plus George Will, Sam Donaldson, Cokie Roberts, assorted news-making guests, and ”our man Jack Smith” reporting from Washington
* The Rules Be self-confident. Be wry. Yea, offer all things unto all brunch eaters: news, background reporting, interviews, discussion, commentary, and sardonic asides.
* What to Watch For The (many) moments when Brinkley’s face telegraphs ”Politics! What a dump!”
* Grade: A For excellence

WASHINGTON WEEK IN REVIEW
* The Players Moderator Paul Duke, three modulated journalists, understated glasses of water, and a big conference table
* The Rules The polite, literate, civilized conversation expected of colleagues as familiar with one another as old wing tips. No pushing or shoving, please.
* What to Watch For Whether tea is actually served or we just imagine that it is
* Grade: B- For courtesy

Comments